1. Mortgage
  2. Resources
  3. Mortgage follow-up benchmarks

Benchmarks

Mortgage follow-up benchmarks, October 2026

These are the published figures behind our workflows: how fast lenders answer new leads, how many pre-approved buyers go elsewhere, how few past clients return, and why agents switch loan officers. Each one is dated and linked to its source, with what it does not show.

New leads and pre-approvals

How fast lenders answer, who never hears back, and where pre-approved buyers go.

  • 21x better odds of convertingA mortgage lead reached within 5 minutes had 21 times the odds of converting of one reached after 30 minutes, an Insellerate speed-to-contact study of mortgage lenders found (2020).Insellerate, 2020. Recorded October 20, 2026. What it does not show
  • 40% of mortgage leads never contactedAbout 40% of mortgage leads are never contacted, and the average reply to a mortgage lead takes 6 hours, Insellerate found (2021).Insellerate, 2021 Comprehensive MBA Contact Study. Recorded October 20, 2026. What it does not show
  • 1 in 3 of lost buyers go to another loan officerOf the buyers a loan officer loses, 1 in 3 go to another loan officer, STRATMOR and ICE data show (2024 to 2026).STRATMOR Group and ICE, customer-experience benchmarks, 2024 to 2026. Recorded October 20, 2026. What it does not show
  • 93 daysOn LenderLogix’s platform in the third quarter of 2026, the average buyer spent about 93 days between pre-approval and application, after 8.3 pre-approval letters. Of its QuickQuals, 53% became applications.LenderLogix Homebuyer Intelligence Report, Q3 2026. Last checked October 19, 2026. What it does not show
  • 3% of a loan officer’s leads closeAbout 3% of a loan officer’s leads close, against 30 to 50% of referral leads (BankingBridge, 2023; leadPops, 2026).BankingBridge, Mortgage Lead Conversion Part I, April 2023, and leadPops, 2026. Last checked October 20, 2026. What it does not show

Past clients and rate drops

Who says they would come back, and who actually does.

  • 82% walk away for their next loan82% of borrowers walk away and don’t return for their next loan, STRATMOR reports (2025). Its reading of why: after closing, “the communication drops off dramatically.”STRATMOR Group, Strangers No More, 2025. Last checked October 15, 2026. What it does not show
  • 71% forget their loan officer71% of clients forget their loan officer within 13 months (Homebot, 2018).Homebot, 2018. Recorded October 21, 2026. What it does not show
  • 72% of refinancers poached by other lendersIn the third quarter of 2025, 72% of borrowers who refinanced got poached by other lenders: the company that held their loan kept 28%, ICE found.ICE Mortgage Monitor, December 2025. Last checked October 21, 2026. What it does not show
  • 72% of investors use two or more loan officers72% of real estate investors work with two or more loan officers (NAR).NAR. Recorded October 21, 2026. What it does not show

Referral partners

Which loan officer agents use, and why they switch.

  • 41.9% of high-producing agents changed #1 loan officer41.9% of high-producing agents (10 or more buyer-side sales a year) had a different #1 loan officer a year later, Mortgage Market Intelligence found across 88,823 agents (2026).Mortgage Market Intelligence, Intel #35, August 2026. Recorded October 20, 2026. What it does not show
  • 12% of agents send all their deals to one loan officer12% of agents send all their deals to one loan officer, STRATMOR found. The other 88% send their deals to multiple loan officers.STRATMOR. Recorded October 21, 2026. What it does not show
  • 1 to 3 loans a year from one agentOne agent sends about 1 to 3 loans a year to their main loan officer (NAR, 2024 to 2026).NAR, Member Profile, 2024 to 2026. Recorded October 20, 2026. What it does not show
  • 56% rank responsiveness first55.7% of agents named a loan officer’s responsiveness and communication the single most important factor in recommending a closing services provider.The Real Brokerage, July 2025 Agent Survey, Business Wire, August 2025. Last checked October 16, 2026. What it does not show

Time

What AI drafting does to writing time.

  • 40% less writing timeWith an AI writing assistant, professionals finished writing tasks 40% faster and the quality of their work rose 18%, a study in Science found (2023).Noy and Zhang, MIT, Science, 2023. Last checked October 20, 2026. What it does not show

Glossary

The terms this site uses, in plain words.

Speed to lead
How quickly a loan officer replies after a new lead arrives.
Pre-approval
A lender’s early check of a buyer’s income, assets and credit, made before the buyer has chosen a home or applied.
NMLS
The Nationwide Multistate Licensing System. Every licensed mortgage loan originator has an NMLS number, and our messages go out under yours.
TCPA
The Telephone Consumer Protection Act, the federal law on calling and texting people. Compliance with it stays with the loan officer. This is a plain gloss, not legal advice.
Webhook
A webhook is a message one program sends another when something happens.
Zapier
Zapier is a service that links one app to another.

Last reviewed

Stop leaving loans on the table.

Fifteen minutes on your business, and an honest answer on fit.

15 minutesBook a call